
I haven’t been following US politics much lately so this is why I only recently found out about this issue: a John McCain back bill to have the FDA regulate dietary supplements.
This comes after there had been several complaints (even deaths) due to tainted supplements in US. For Senator McCain, i guess the thinking is that a regulatory agency could force supplement companies to implement procedures to ensure the public’s health. It seems however that a lot of people don’t see it that way.
A very vocal group of people opposing this bill states that the goal is the make help pharmaceuticals that feel threaten by the “natural health” industry.
Now, I have no doubt that lobbyists from the pharmaceutical industry would welcome such a bill, but saying that this would be McCain’s only reason for doing it is ludicrous. I’ve had to deal with the FDA and I can tell you that they are not in bed with pharmaceuticals. What I mean by that is that the agency does not favour a particular company over another. If Pfizer were to make drugs in a basement with no safety precautions whatsoever, the FDA would shut them down immediately. Similarly, a supplement company that follows FDA regulations will not have any problems. What is important however is that the people chosen to enact those regulations know the industry and its customers well. They need to have a good understanding of what is important and what is not to ensure that whoever takes those dietary supplements can do so safely.
Back to Canada, we are apparently in the process of regulating this industry. The bill has passed and natural health companies are getting registered (although the complaint here is that this process is very slow). It seems that there aren’t many advocates of no regulation here.
To finish, I just wanted to share an argument I’ve heard against regulation. It is the idea that a lot of small natural health companies will not be able to pass the inspections and will have to close, adding to unemployment. Now, if this is true, this shows a problem with the industry since such a statement is similar to saying that food regulations for restaurants are not good because they shut down a dirty diner.